The more time I spend thinking about a parking lot in place of a park
But it's not a parking lot
in place of a park...they're putting a park on top of the parking lot, just like Hidalgo.
My previous response now that I read it is quite strident and rigid in my stance. In fact and over time now that I've had a chance to think about it and talk to some of my local friends, on the south side parking is desperately needed. I spent the better part of my 19 day trip last year in cars with local friends as we drove around on occasions for up to 45 minutes looking for parking ANYwhere within a 10 block radius of the Olas Altas area. More often than not with no luck.
Do I agree with tearing up a park to create this? No, not really. There were better areas around there they could have looked at first, IMO. However I'm now going back on my original inflexible response and saying I'm going to wait and see how they do this, how they handle it, and the final result. I've seen new pictures of Hidalgo and it seems as though it is getting more use now than it was originally. Do I like it? No, I still think it's a wee bit too "sterile" for my taste and doesn't have enough foliage, but whaddya gonna do. It seems the Mexican families like it - they're using it again.
As Vallarta develops more of a middle class, and Mexico now has automobile financing available to nationals, more and more local people are purchasing autos...and the infrastructure just wasn't prepared for the influx of more cars. Still isn't, and that's why you see so much more traffic, more traffic jams, etc. And why you also see so much kerfuffle these days about parking, parking stalls, parking garages. It's a hot potato issue, and not just amongst the locals.
What I do wish is that they had taken those trees out and replanted them somewhere else for the duration of the construction instead of pruning them to within an inch of their lives. But of course, it's hard for us to apply our own knowledge of construction/environmental standards to Mexico, because theirs are drastically different. And as guests in their country, we have to accept that.
EDIT: I admit I'm far more horrified to see the outright tearing down and destroying of all the live foliage on the grounds of the former Molino de Agua than I am to see a heavily pruned tree at Cardenas. What's been done there is a flat out abomination. Again, foliage that could have been just as easily transported and transplanted elsewhere and it was just cut right down to make room for the new crass condo development that's going in. Blech.