Advice on boat tours. Geronimo or Day Off?

We will be in PV on 1/18 and would like to take a tour. Both Geronimo and the Day Off Cruise look fun. Any suggestions as to which one?

I went on the Geronimo tour in Jan/02 and we really enjoyed it. Saw lots of dolphins and whales were breaching! Also got to go scuba diving and snorkeling at Marietas and another beach on north side.